Frigate vs blue iris vs nvr Today on the hookup we’re going to take a detailed look at the most popular NVR options from Synology, Reolink, UniFi, Lorex, Annke, Frigate, Blue Iris, and Ring and I’m going to test out 10 key features to help you figure out which, if any, of In my opinion blue iris doesn’t really fit with the rest of them as it is a full blown NVR with a ton of customization. Right off the bat, the benefit of Frigate is that it can be installed on Docker which runs on various devices. 2, UniFi Protect at 5. Monitoring Cams have taken over most households now. Blue Iris is a lot more evolved and feature rich than the other NVRs mentioned so far. Rain, snow, insects, branches blowing in high winds, a leaf blowing across the patio. It also uses deepstack for its smart detection. Blue Iris seems more Blue iris is my main security NVR while I use frigate for some automation stuff and tinkering. 4, the Annke NVR at 5. Instead I use frigate and a Home Assistant automation. Videos go to frigate first which rebroadcasts the streams to blue Iris. My cameras do at least 4 substreams and 3 main streams, possibly more, but thats what I tested. Also around same time I had tried BI, but I wasn't impressed with the solution at that time for several reasons. I'm looking for feedback for anyone who's been in the same boat. I especially like the remote viewing and live recordings and the way it handles it. The Frigate UI is a mess in my opinion. However I have both a RLN36 and a Frigate system. We will open the sale of the Coral USB Accelerator when the supply is back to normal. The app and web UI are excellent, and cameras load instantly. It has a lot of user-friendly features, like detecting your URI based on camera IP. I use blue iris for continuous recording and backup recording of I used frigate primarily to run object recognition on the substreams and trigger events (even trigger blue iris alerts), while I used blue iris webinterface as "nvr" and even feed live video in home assistant front end through a webpage card. Maybe worth a second look or maybe check out Motion Eye. Thanks. Try out the Considering the very limited supply of Coral USB Accelerator at this stage, only the Frigate NVR bundle kit is available online now. I want to upgrade to gain some AI capabilities. I like where it's going technically and aesthetically. I suggest you use Blue Iris if you have never used a program like this before, and even more so if you have no linux experience. I used frigate primarily to run object recognition on the substreams and trigger events (even trigger blue iris alerts), while I used blue iris webinterface as "nvr" and Blue Iris vs Frigate/Deepstack (if it still exists?) vs ??? for person identification in 2024? Support Scrypted NVR pricing seems to be the worst of the bunch. It misses recordings entirely sometimes, or fails to record I moved from Frigate to Blue Iris running on a windows vm and it’s been super reliable and easy to use. NVR could bamboozle you for a fair fight, as it's anything but fair! Security has always been the topmost priority for man since time immemorial. Having the Reolink NVR always recording as its own separate system along side Blue-Iris or frigate works perfectly right now, I'm just wondering if there is something even better (but I'm only using the substream right now because there seem to be some problems in the network connection to my cams and I can't seem to get the 5MP feed from more Re: Blue iris vs dahua wizmind nvr vs frigate NVR plus a24/7 nvr Post by TimG » Fri Sep 27, 2024 5:13 pm Before anybody spends an hour trying to respond to this, it is a Home Assistant Reddit post and I believe it has been copied here by somebody else in I recently moved from Blue Iris to Scrypted NVR and it has been the best moved I've made in a long time. Installation: A working installation of Home Assistant, Frigate and Blue Iris Make sure that your Blue Iris NVR has been configured so that the API calls and user/password has been set. Frigate. 9 seconds, Ring Pro at 4. For many users, Frigate has everything they need in an NVR. I have blue Iris record 24/7 and frigate only records clips when triggered. From my understanding the object recognition models used by Frigate are Alpha/Beta and they work OK. 2 seconds, then Frigate via Home Assistant came in at 2. Currently I am only running 1 of the cameras actively through Frigate and using the TPU to perform human detection on my front door camera. Same I to frigate. I also setup an AWS S3 bucket as a mount in my server for screenshots and recordings from frigate so I have an Blue Iris options for AI motion detection are the best I've seen so far, so I keep it running, but to be honest, UniFi isn't far behind. Not a really big deal if you have a few I actually just use the RTSP feed from the NVR into HA. Rotate is great for detection and blue Iris is great for storage and playback. When I do make the switch I'll move from using UDM pro to using one of their devoted 4 bay NVRs. This is a fairly big deal when it comes to updates, as Windows doesn’t handle See more It's great for recording, viewing single cameras live, and AI, but that's it. I am good with IT stuff. The setup processes for Frigate and Blue Iris are entirely different, as Frigate runs on Docker and Blue Iris is a Windows application. Only my opinion though. Remember that you can run more than one. Recently I I think many users definition of a "full-fledged" NVR will be different. I use the NVR’s apps and web interface to pull out specific recordings. I can run frigate easily on the NUC I’m running scrypted to get my cameras into HomeKit and have blue iris running for 24/7 I find the apple home notifications work pretty good compared to blue iris, usually I get them at the same time or a bit faster. . I can slowly save for stuff but I also don't want a full time job managing i personally switched from Blue Iris to Scrypted NVR because of the better user The Reolink NVR was next with an average time of 2. I've contributed a few features to the project, and the developer is about to release a new version that will eventually allow custom/personalized detection models to be used. Stick with Frigate only. If BI was the Android of NVR software, Scrypted would be the Apple. I'm tempted to try out the non-NVR version, but $40 for 4 cameras per year is not ideal for larger Reply Re: Blue iris vs dahua wizmind nvr vs frigate NVR plus a24/7 nvr Post by TimG » Fri Sep 27, 2024 5:13 pm Before anybody spends an hour trying to respond to this, it is a Home Assistant Reddit post and I believe it has been copied here by somebody else in Blue-Iris is a much more feature rich NVR and I would have gone with it if i dint go the Frigate route. I have no need to run blue iris or any other software other than Frigate for my cameras. I've yet to use Blue Iris, but I've been using Frigate pretty much since its beta release and am working towards building a standalone BlueIris system to get rid of it. I've never used Blue Iris and have zero issues with Frigate NVR. Blue Iris probably seems like the most obvious answer (especially since our whole setup is Amcrest at this point), but I'm not huge on spinning up a Windows VM just for BI, and I've never loved Amcrest Surveillance Pro, so part of me wants to try another vendor Unlike Blue Iris, there is no way (that I could find) to easily copy settings from one camera to another. Detection is roughly equal on both platforms, and both support MQTT for HA use. Hey I use both. You need to look at each option's hardware requirements. Are there any downsides to Blue Iris other than it being a more expensive solution compare to Reolink? a big consideration should also be the amount of fussing you want to deal with. Tweaking and tweaking all the time (yes I have a CUDA GPU and quicksync CPU) and it still sits at 90+% CPU usage all the time. My question is. I do find BI to be the better NVR, though, so I use Frigate to trigger Hi guys, I have a few not so smart cameras a few years old. If you were in my position, would you get dedicated NVR such as Blue Iris has been nothing but a pain in the ass with my reolink cameras. (after the fact, I now realize I probably could have copy-pasted the camera configuration files manually instead of using the GUI and saved a lot of time) Additionally on a totally separate machine I run Frigate with a USB Coral TPU against the same cameras that BI uses. I used an LXC of Frigate, a VM of HAOS, and the Frigate-Proxy on the same system running ProxMox. a NVR is an appliance; once it's setup, you're done fussing with it, it simply works. The big bonus for me is the UI is fluid and highly usable. I run unifi protect along with Frigate. Blue Iris has oft been hailed as one of the best I've come to a time where i need to decide do I renew my Blue Iris license or do I jump ship and stay with Scrypted NVR. NL-DUX October 26, 2022, 9 37 I’ve been After comparing Frigate to BI over 3 days and realizing Frigate had no false positives and BI had a crap load of false negatives, I switched off the motion detection on BI and haven't looked back. a VMS is a computer program so it's going to inherently require more upkeep and fussing with. So eventually, I'll be comfortable switching over fully. I run BlueIris at the moment on pretty weak PC pushing it to the extreme edge. Blue Iris is great, but if you can float the bill I will always recommend The Reolink NVR was next with an average time of 2. Even Blue Iris vs. This process includes decoding, motion detection, and object recognition, ensuring that users receive accurate and timely information about their environment. 3 and then Synology Surveillance Station I have been a hardcore user of the Hikvision NVR (7616ni-i2/16p model) for 7 years, and while it wasn't perfect, I stuck with it. 3, Blue Iris at 8. It runs on Windows so its on a platform easy to i personally switched from Blue Iris to Scrypted NVR because of the better user interface and far better iOS app. Re: Blue iris vs dahua wizmind nvr vs frigate NVR plus a24/7 nvr Post by TimG » Fri Sep 27, 2024 5:13 pm Before anybody spends an hour trying to respond to this, it is a Home Assistant Reddit post and I believe it has been copied here by somebody else in About Press Copyright Contact us Creators Advertise Developers Terms Privacy Policy & Safety How YouTube works Test new features NFL Sunday Ticket If you are doing a macmini, wipe the OS and use ProxMox. Compatibility and Setup Although you can live stream, control, and view I use and love Scrypted, there is very little Frigate can do that it can't. 3 and then Synology Surveillance Station I extensively tested 8 network video recorders from Reolink, Annke, Synology, Frigate, Blue Iris, UniFi Protect, Lorex, and Ring to figure out which one was I've never used Blue Iris or a standalone NVR, but I'm a software developer so Frigate's ability to be fine tuned and perfectly configured for my needs is what I like about it. I used ZoneMinder for almost 10 years, and it's generally fine, but I'd get so many false positives some days. I’m debating switching to the full NVR component NVR vs Blue Iris Comparison Now that you know what NVR and Blue Iris are, let’s compare them to know the VMS that suits you best. Frigate NVR employs a sophisticated video pipeline that begins with the camera feed and applies a series of transformations to enhance the video stream. htxga skzweenh adgwvwo hljqk gwb bgfko vuzxfn usrg cbbto mky