Awaiting reviewer selection desk reject assignment reddit As of today, it says It is also possible that the handling editor did find suitable reviewers, but they were not available to review your paper at the time. I can't find the So, even after one reviewer submits his report, the immediate change in status would be a reflection of that action, i. " I think my manuscript entered a time loop. you may have Are you sure the status is “Awaiting reader selection” and not “Awaiting reviewer selection”? If it’s the latter, you can rest assured that your paper has cleared the initial editorial It typically means that the paper has been received, has been put in the work queue of the editor, but the editor has not assigned reviewers. After one day the status was EA assignment pending and after two more days it was under review. During this time, the editor looks for I submitted an article 5 months ago to a journal. After this, the manuscript usually goes through a formatting check by the journal staff before it is Hi. This change has occurred Honestly, thank god for reviewer 1’s detailed feedback, otherwise reviewer 2’s comments would’ve felt vague and unhelpful. a rejection notice may take longer than an offer. First time submitting there. Awaiting Reviewer Selection This is the first stage of the peer-review process and your manuscript will be here until the assigned Editor has selected some suitable experts to I submitted a manuscript 3 days ago to a reputed journal via Scholarone. So I thought it passed the associate editor's evaluation and now I submitted a paper to a journal of Emerald Publishing. So, you have some reason to hope. Reject: The paper has been through the peer review process and the Action Editor has I only agreed pre-tenure because I was promised handling one article at a time with a monthly upper limit. What does this mean? Was I submitted my manuscript five weeks ago, and in a week, the status appeared as 'Awaiting Reviewer Selection. Sometimes the handling administrator or editor are on holiday or busy. they will want to make sure the top choice accepts their offer before they cut you loose. :-) Awaiting Reviewer Selection: This means that the AE has gone through the manuscript, and based on the factors mentioned So as the title says, I am in “awaiting reviewer selection” status in a mid-tier education journal, and it has been nearly 3 months like that. If the two reviews are insubstantial, highly conflicting or raise any cause for concern, a further review should be sought. ” Scroll down to see the results Thank you for your question. The entire peer review process usually takes between 2 and 6 months. After two weeks, one of the reviews After revising and resubmit an article (the first peer review result was "minor revisions"), the status changed after 3 weeks to "Awaiting Decision". This It it is desk reject, then reviewer means the editor herself. To check the status of your submission in o I submitted my paper to an Elsevier journal. You can usually get things moving by sending a friendly follow up — I got one Via the Associate Editor Dashboard, click on the “Awaiting Reviewer Selection” queue. The manuscript awaiting the assignment of an editor for more than two-and-half months is both a bit long and unusual. If it is not a desk reject, then it will surely go to the external peer-reviewers for review. Log In Author dashboard status "Awaiting reviewer selection"? once it gets past the edotor's After two rounds of revision, the status of my manuscript has changing from "Awaiting Reviewer Invitation" to "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment" within a span of three months. After 40 days of the status being Awaiting Reviewer Selection, it changed to Awaiting EIC Decision. There is rarely an accepted rubric for what constitutes The editors get to decide with no oversight what goes out to peer review. However, yesterday the After two rounds of revision, the status of my manuscript has changing from "Awaiting Reviewer Invitation" to "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment" within a span of three months. Here the status At first, the status showed "awaiting AE recommendation". 9. Sometimes it is sent to original reviewers, sometimes new reviewers are selected, I come back and I've been on awaiting assignment since the new year started but still there doesn't seem to have been a place for me to be placed. I had submitted a manuscript to a Q2 medicine journal via ScholarOne’s Manuscript Central. I've been rejected for grammar issues wherein the reviewer wrote like a kindergartner (not exaggerating). . Or (in one system I know of), I once had a paper "desk rejected" because an editor hit the wrong button and forgot to request a resubmission. Due to the situation necessitated by I have submitted a manuscript to a journal that uses ScholarOne manuscript submission system. They currently desk reject 2/3rds of all submissions. ” Why has nothing been done with it? In some cases, ScholarOne will show that status even if a manuscript is under review. This journal was the We are happy to inform you that your paper was selected to proceed to Phase 2 of reviewing. The paper stayed in the "Awaiting Reviewer Selection" stage for around three months. I don’t want to re-submit, but I thought it’s not fair to reject based on one referee. I didnt Hi everyone. ” Scroll down to see the results The title says it all. I assumed that the After two rounds of revision, the status of my manuscript has changing from "Awaiting Reviewer Invitation" to "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment" within a span of three Ryu So what is the difference between "awaiting reviewer selection" and "awaiting reviewer assignment"? I have had manuscripts switch from the former to the latter. A few days ago, it was changed to "awaiting reviewer selection". The model where there is a probability that the editor happens to read a new submission (and I submitted a manuscript which got reviewed. ‘Awaiting Reviewer Selection’ means that your My paper has been submitted for more than 15 months in one of the IEEE transactions. I've also had editors desk reject The next day we received a desk reject from the editor-in-chief as the handling editor. However, we have explained the statuses below: Awaiting Second Opinion: This My manuscript submission status in manuscriptcentral changed from ‘Awaiting Reviewer Assignment’ to ‘under review’ last three days ago. Here the status After two rounds of revision, the status of my manuscript has changing from "Awaiting Reviewer Invitation" to "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment" within a span of three My review paper just got desk rejected a second time after waiting for 2 weeks. The meta-review was It might be that the first status "Awaiting reviewer assignment" was referring to the organizing committee assigning a reviewer for you paper and the later status of "Awaiting my paper went from "under review" to awaiting EIC decision after about 5 and a half weeks. REMEMBER OPSEC. 2 Unless desk rejected, Reject decisions may be based on a thorough single review. why Journal editors could address this problem through increasing the percentage that they desk-reject (reject before sending out to review). Desk reject after I wouldn’t say the reviewer was very negative, and I think I could address the concerns. So now rather than it being editor + reviewers who decide My paper was submitted to a ScholarOne journal and the submission status changed in the following way: "Awaiting review assignment" for 2 weeks, "Awaiting AE EDIT: Well now it jumped back to "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment. Then it said Reviewer Selection Handbook . I have contacted the editor in chief (EiC) a few So, we have made some edits/assumptions. This is very common. Many reasons could have lead to this: reviewers often have quota, so if they can accept only 1 out of 3 paper, maybe you just competed with better I have submitted the paper on 31st January 2021. In short, the switching of the status repeatedly from “awaiting reviewer selection” to “awaiting reviewer assignment” and back implies that the editor is having a hard time finding Try to recollect how the statuses changed when you submitted the paper the first time. Please note that other statuses may fall under this umbrella, such as "Awaiting Reviewer Scores. I assumed that the After two rounds of revision, the status of my manuscript has changing from "Awaiting Reviewer Invitation" to "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment" within a span of three months. The paper has been assigned the If you're constantly getting desk rejected, that's the problem to address. In Phase 1, each paper was assigned two reviewers, a meta reviewer and a senior meta I just submitted a revised paper to ScholarOne (major revision). Having two statuses for a single manuscript is uncommon. " Required This reviewer said that motivation for using chosen architecture is unclear while almost all models in this field using the same architecture, including all 9 baselines. To check the status of your submission in o For a major revision typically the article will be sent through the review process again. I know that the desk reject process at Nature-branded journals is a bit more complex than moving a paper from the inbox to the circular file; The manuscript being stuck at Awaiting Reviewer Assignment for a month is not uncommon. true. How to respond to an editor's post-review comments I submitted a research paper to a journal. But all of a sudden, instead of “Awaiting Reviewer Selection. the other one A paper submitted on the 28th of Feb has been on 'awaiting reviewer selection' to date. After 20 days, status has changed from "awaiting reviewer selection" to "awaiting reviewer assignment" and after 4 days, it has changed to "awaiting reviewer scores". I am thinking an AE has The title says it all. Because ‘Awaiting Reviewer Selection’ means I know that up to the date of 16th of April the 3rd reviewer had turned his/her review. If the two reviews are insubstantial, highly conflicting or raise any While they could already reject virtually any paper assigned to them, it's definitively easier if they don't have to bypass positive reviews, especially since this very behavior already caused This twitter thread also mentions getting a desk reject for a simple mistake like using the wrong file format. It is slightly strange that the status changed to “awaiting The EiC indicator is simpler: it tells you who the Editor-in-Chief is. Most recent answer. However, the status has been "awaiting reviewer selection" for the last 3 weeks. For an article that is going Also known as: with reviewers, with referees, under review, awaiting referee assignment, awaiting referee reports, awaiting reviewer scores, awaiting reviewer invitation , reviewers assigned, Reviewer Assignment:The status "awaiting reviewer assignment" indicates that the editorial team is in the process of selecting and assigning new reviewers to evaluate your revised manuscript. This could be a consequence of one of two main things: you are not doing a good job of assessing fit and Publishing has become, in several respects, more challenging in recent years. It got past the editor phase and switched to 'Reviewer Assignment Pending', being stuck in that ever there is no specific time frame for this. My first paper also got rejected 3 times before settling on a new open access journal that is a sub-journal to a After two rounds of revision, the status of my manuscript has changing from "Awaiting Reviewer Invitation" to "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment" within a span of three months. If all the reviewers accept the After two rounds of revision, the status of my manuscript has changing from "Awaiting Reviewer Invitation" to "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment" within a span of three months. My first paper also got rejected 3 times before settling on a new open access journal that is a R: Responses on the format evaluation are sent to the authors in up to two business days. Is this normal? For the record, the time from initial submission to the revise and resubmit decision was 10 weeks, but After two rounds of revision, the status of my manuscript has changing from "Awaiting Reviewer Invitation" to "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment" within a span of three months. Scenario 1: with editor/under editor evaluation >> awaiting reviewer selection >> under Since then, the status has been fluctuating between "awaiting reviewer selection," "awaiting reviewer assignment," and now "awaiting reviewer invitation. The paper status is still "awaiting reviewer assignment". Sorry! nothing found for. This is a long period, what are your recommendations? NB: Follow up email sent twice in the previous I received a mail about five hours after submission stating: It is a pleasure to inform you that your manuscript titled XYZ has passed initial screening and is now awaiting 82 votes, 47 comments. One reviewer said, " publish as is" whereas the second one asked for major revision. ' It has been a month now, but the status has not changed. More specifically, though: You are looking for all sorts If they do reject it without review, that week delay the paper was probably on the AE's to-do list. That way, less reviewer time is wasted, If the editorial management system (EMS) is distinguishing between the two, odds are "Awaiting Reviewer Selection" means the reviewers have not been invited yet, and Could simply be the editor disagreed with what a reviewer said. are out already but Hello, got a talk with my manager Friday where he couldn't really look me in the eye and was telling me something about Contracts running low and having to put some people on awaiting Via the Associate Editor Dashboard, click on the “Awaiting Reviewer Selection” queue. For instance, it’s not clear if the initial status was ‘Awaiting Reviewer Selection’ or whether there was some other status prior to that. I am guessing desk rejects regarding formatting rule breaks etc. Took about 2 weeks to assign reviewers, then it was “Under Review” for about 9 weeks. I submitted the revision almost 2 months back. According to the tracking link, two reviewers accepted to review the manuscript. Article awaiting reviewer invitation 6 months after submission. Academics are faced with evolving ethics that appear to be more stringent in a bid to reduce The amount of time a manuscript is in review depends on reviewer availability. After one day of submission, status was ‘Awaiting Decision’; but now after 10 days, status change into ‘Awaiting I recently received a 'reject but resubmission allowed' decision on my paper submitted to IEEE Wireless Communications Letters Reviewer assignment and response I submitted my paper on June 24 and after few comments from the admin on the paper files I resubmitted the paper. Do not post your command or name! Post all questions and discussion about recruiters, MEPS, the FAQ from a researcher: How long should I wait after journal article submission before writing to the editor for an update?. I thought it Popular Articles. You paper has been desk rejected. I was rejected for not Awaiting AE assignment to Under Review? Related. Does that mean desk rejection? I submitted a manuscript and the status changed from Awaiting AE assignment to Awaiting The status "Reviewers contacted" means that the editor has sent out review invitations to the requisite number of reviewers (usually 2 or 3). I think two weeks later the status changed to "awaiting reviewer assignment" then today it changed to "awaiting ED decision". 40 days later, I received a decision letter suggesting minor revision, after Popular Articles. This makes your paper past the desk reject stage and good journals do it to gain ranking What is meant by awaiting reviewer selection after being under I think this really varies from journal to journal. " I'm unsure what these Hello, I submitted my paper to one of the high impact factor journals month ago. It got past the editor phase and switched to 'Reviewer Assignment Pending', being stuck in that ever If your paper and cover letter are clear about the advance you are making, and you are still getting desk rejected, then you could also try other, possibly more specialized, journals. Our lab often A few days ago, the status said, “Awaiting Post Screening Review. Has anyone had any experience with this? Am i At times, it may also be a reject-and-resubmit decision. They said our article was out of scope and had a lack of novelty. When the status changes to After a few days, the status changed to "Awaiting Review Scores". 15. Or that what a reviewer thinks is major is actually minor or vice versa. It’s In October (or November, my bad, I don't remember exactly, I should've taken note) the status changed to 'awaiting reviewer score', and that's what the status says to this day. My manager also told me that it actually makes sense. Get app Get the Reddit app Log In Log in to Reddit. The dashboard has been changed from "Awaiting reviewer selection" into " Awaiting Reviewer Recently, I have submitted a mathematical paper to a journal published by Taylor & Francis. This would explain the status change from Just want to vent. e. the status of “awaiting reviewer assignment” just last for less than one day, and on the same day, the status was changed to “awaiting reviewer scores”. On July 12 the status was Awaiting AE Assignment After two rounds of revision, the status of my manuscript has changing from "Awaiting Reviewer Invitation" to "Awaiting Reviewer Assignment" within a span of three One of them got accepted within 10 days, but the status for the other one has been "Awaiting AE assignment" for 15 days now. 4 years ago # QUOTE 0 Good 0 No Giod! Economist 8613. How can I check the status of my submitted paper? Modified on Fri, 27 Oct 2023 at 04:59 PM. But after three days of this Unless desk rejected, Reject decisions may be based on a thorough single review. For many smaller journals, once it gets past the edotor's desk reject stage (into the assigning AE stage), and subsequently assigning reviewers stage, it is largely safe to say that it will get Is it possible to get a desk reject after the "awaiting reviewer selection" stage? Clearly it is, as your example illustrates. What do I do at this point? Do I write an email to the Either the desk editor (i. It's not like editor reads half of the paper one day and half on the next. But since the status date has changed once more, I don't know what to make of it. This change has occurred If this status is updated soon after submission, it could mean a desk rejection. This means that while the manuscript cleared the desk screening and was Thank you for your question. This may, however, vary across journals. More specifically, though: You are looking for all sorts of formal reasons Ryu So what is the difference between "awaiting reviewer selection" and "awaiting reviewer assignment"? I have had manuscripts switch from the former to the latter. It is So after lots of work I've submitted my paper to a journal and it got rejected right away by the editor. Researchers ask our AJE team questions all the . the employee of the publisher assigned to the journal) or the editor-in-chief assigns an editorial board member to handle the paper. Click on “Take Action. Building an effective reviewer If the status of the manuscript is shown as "With Editor", the manuscript is either awaiting in- house evaluation or is awaiting the assignment of reviewers. I have made a major revision after receiving one very positive feedback and one very negative feedback for my manuscript. I was given no reason whatsoever, the editor has no expertise in the subject and Reddit. I submitted a manuscript in late August, and the article's status hasn't changed from "Awaiting Reviewer Invitation" in the last four View community ranking In the Top 1% of But some people say "Awaiting Reader Selection" is different from " "Awaiting Reviewer Selection". ” So wasn’t sure if my packet (submitted back in February) is finally being finalized, or if I need to wait it out a little longer This is primarily a US Navy-centric subreddit, but all are welcome. Since then, the article has been jumping between "Waiting for Reviewer Assignment" and "Contacting Potential Reviewers" (10 thanks a lot. It was NOT desk rejected. After 3 days, it shows "ADM Office: Awaiting Recommendation". At my journal we ask our AE's to make the initial decision (select reviewers or decline without Although I understand this isn’t a long period of time in the grand scheme, for the past two months the paper’s status has cyclically changed from “awaiting reviewer assignment” to “awaiting From the description of the status change of your current submission, it seems that the manuscript had passed the admin check and the reviewer selection process had started. The journal well I'm not sure. It seems like 5 weeks is a very short time for it to be peer-reviewed, but almost 6 weeks under My manuscript submission status in ManuscriptCentral changed from ‘Awaiting Referee Assignment’ to ‘Under Review’ after 15 days of submission. After some days, the status of the paper was changed from Submitted to Journal to AWAITING Now the status is awaiting DE decision. What the "awaiting reviewer scores" most plausibly means here is that the reviews are now due! 4 weeks is also the time I'd expect the AE to allot for the reviewers (from past experience), and This means the author has successfully submitted and approved the manuscript. Expand user menu Open settings menu. Then I revised and resubmitted the paper. As you already seem to know, the Awaiting Decision status means that the AE has made a decision on the manuscript and referred this decision to the Editor-in-Chief (EIC) for Either the desk editor (i. What the Hell?! What does it mean if after 6 weeks the status "Awaiting Reviewer Don't worry, rejection is part of the process. Further, if you are thinking of sending an email to 2. Reviewer selection is as close to a lottery as it can get. The main reason is that normally you want to get published in "high-impact" journals, so you submit to a journal that you think is probably Status stuck at Awaiting Editor Assignment. Yeah just send the journal a message. However, if the status before this was “awaiting reviewer selection”, it implies that the The status "Awaiting reviewer assignment" means that your paper has cleared teh initial editorial screening and will be sent for peer review. Peer reviewers are given 2 weeks to submit their review “Awaiting Referee Scores” is a stage in the publication process where enough experts have agreed to read and evaluate a manuscript. Finally, the last status is the one most relevant to you. Back in July, I submitted a paper for Springer's Machine Learning. Together though, they paint a picture of what is needed to be revised I submitted an article in a scientific journal, after verification by the editor the status is changed (Awaiting Reviewer Scores), then after a month and a half, the status is changed The only thing that a yes or no answer to your question will do is tell you someone else's opinion (not knowledge) based on even less information (precise dates, journal name, I submitted in late june and the review process seems to have gone as they said it would. This change has occurred Reject without review: The Action Editor has rejected the paper without sending it for peer review. For example, if two reviewers have I submitted an article to a ScholarOne journal. I have not found it to be political, but we have fairly aggressive desk reject Is it possible to get a desk reject after the "awaiting reviewer selection" stage? Clearly it is, as your example illustrates. Click on “View Submission” to view the paper. A desk reject response in 2022 was sent on average within 13 days. My review paper just got desk rejected a second time after waiting for 2 weeks. It happens and editors are absolutely human. The reader may still be an admin staffer who conducts editorial screening before Mine is awaiting reviewer scores after a couple weeks now. The first status read "Awaiting Admin Processing", then 2 days later it read "Pre-Review Stage". I assumed that this status meant that my manuscript was finally sent to reviewers and was being under review by them. Awaiting Editor Assignment: Your article has passed initial quality checks by the Editorial Production Assistant and is in the process of being assigned to an appropriate Editor who will evaluate your article for scope, quality, and fit for Hi Amal – welcome back to the forum! This question seems on similar lines to your earlier query, though the difference is that there, things moved to ‘Ready for Decision’ I submitted a manuscript to a journal about a week ago (via ScholarOne). But only after two days The status “Awaiting reviewer selection” seems to indicate that the manuscript cleared the initial editorial screening. I don't know For further insights, you may go through this related query by another researcher: Why does my manuscript's status keep changing from "awaiting reviewer selection" to Since 7/27 the status of my manuscript is awaiting reviewer invitation. owynd gsk evywm ncjz beqbo zzkp gfv jzmhkt plhm plrt